Seeding Overview / Tillings
Tillings · Tools

Giving Stock Instead of Cash: Why the Asset Can Matter

If you own shares that have grown, how you give can matter as much as how much you give.

Posted September 23, 20264 Min Read

Most generous people give with a check or a card. It is simple and it feels direct. But if you own shares that have grown in value, writing the check may be the more expensive way to give the same amount.

This is one of the most overlooked parts of charitable planning, and it is one of the places a donor-advised fund quietly earns its keep.

Sell First, and Taxes May Come First

Say you want to give to your church. You sell some shares, then write the check. Selling shares that have grown may trigger capital gains tax, so part of that growth goes to taxes before a single dollar reaches the cause.

Nothing wrong was done. It is just the order of operations. Change the order, and the picture can change with it.

This matters most for people who have held the same shares for a long time: an old employer's stock, a position a parent left you, or an account that quietly grew while you were busy running a business. The longer the growth, the bigger the gain sitting inside the shares.

Giving the Shares Directly

Many DAF sponsors accept appreciated stock. Here is how it generally works.

  1. Held Over a Year

    Long-term, publicly traded shares are the usual starting point. Shares held a year or less are generally deductible at no more than what you paid.

  2. No Sale by You

    The sponsor receives the shares, so you generally do not owe gains tax on that growth. The sponsor decides whether and when to sell.

  3. Deduction at Market Value

    If you itemize, the deduction is generally fair market value, limited to 30% of AGI for appreciated stock, with a five-year carryforward.

A Simple Illustration

Say you bought shares years ago for $20,000, and today they are worth $100,000. That is an $80,000 gain.

Path one: sell the shares, then give cash. For illustration only, assume a combined federal rate of 23.8% on the gain, or $19,040 in tax. You could still give $100,000, but you would owe that tax on the sale.

Path two: give the shares to your donor-advised fund. The fund receives the full $100,000 in value, and the tax from selling first generally never comes due for you. If you itemize, you generally deduct the fair market value, within the 30% of AGI limit.

Your bracket, your state and the 2026 rules all change the real numbers. The shape of the comparison is what matters here, and the math belongs with your CPA.

One honest reminder: giving always costs you more than it saves. A deduction lowers your tax by a fraction of the gift, never the whole gift. Give because you want the money to do good, and let the tax rules make that generosity go further.

Same Shares, Same Heart

None of this makes you more generous. The heart that wanted to give is the same heart either way. It just lets more of what you already meant to give reach the work.

Same shares. Same heart. More of it can reach the field.

It also solves a practical problem. Your local church may not have a brokerage account. Your fund can receive the shares, and later you recommend grants in cash to ministries that could never process a stock gift themselves.

Details That Matter

  • Shares that lost value are usually better sold than given. Selling them first and giving the cash is often better, because losses are treated differently. Ask your CPA.
  • Transfers take time. A stock gift generally counts when it lands in the sponsor's account, which can take days to weeks, so start well before December 31.
  • Keep the paperwork. You need the sponsor's written acknowledgment for gifts of $250 or more, including a statement that the sponsor has exclusive legal control. If noncash gifts total over $500 for the year, Form 8283 generally applies.
  • Private assets are different. Noncash gifts over $5,000, other than publicly traded stock, generally need a qualified appraisal, and not every sponsor accepts them.
  • Check the sponsor first. Most sponsors accept publicly traded shares, but minimums, fees and transfer instructions vary, so get them in writing before you call your brokerage.

One Question for Your CPA This Week

Exact results depend on your whole tax picture: your income, your other deductions, your state. So this belongs on your CPA's desk, not on an Instagram post. If you only ask one thing, ask this:

Building a full CPA question list is one of the days in The 7-Day Seed. No purchase required. We do offer paid coaching, and only go into it with people who raise their hand.

The Short Version
  • Selling shares that have grown before you give may mean capital gains tax comes first.
  • Giving long-term appreciated shares directly generally avoids that tax and may be deductible at market value if you itemize.
  • Appreciated stock is generally limited to 30% of AGI, with a five-year carryforward and the 2026 rules on top.
  • Stock takes time to land, so start early and bring the question to your CPA.

This article is education, not tax, legal, or investment advice. Tax results depend on your whole situation. Confirm with your CPA before you act.

Free · The 7-Day Seed

Ready to Seed Your Own Fund?

Start with a free call, then launch your own fund in seven guided days.